errorPlease register the sub image.

Selected Cases

Violation of Subcontracting Law,General Criminal Law

One Law Partners, LLC Successfully Defends Specialty Contractor and Its CEO Against Alleged Illegal Subcontracting to Unregistered Individual Under the Framework Act on the Construction Industry

  • Date 2026.11.20
  • Hit 22

One Law Partners, LLC represented the CEO and corporate entity of a specialty contractor that had been reported for allegedly violating the Framework Act on the Construction Industry by subcontracting insulation work to an individual who was not registered as a construction business operator. By demonstrating, based on the standards established by the Korean Supreme Court, that the company had directly employed the site workers and performed the work itself, One Law Partners, LLC secured non-prosecution (no charges) decisions for both the CEO and the corporation due to insufficient evidence.
 
1. Case Overview
The client is a company engaged in specialty construction contracting.
The company was awarded insulation work and related construction as a subcontractor from a major construction company for the construction of an industrial facility in the Seoul metropolitan area and carried out the work accordingly.
 
During approximately two months of construction, Mr. A, who worked on-site as both an intermediate manager and construction team leader, issued tax invoices to the client under his sole proprietorship business registration, and the client made payments based on those invoices.
 
Relying on these transactions, the complainant alleged that the client had subcontracted the insulation work to Mr. A, who was not registered as a construction business operator, and filed a criminal complaint against the client's CEO. The corporate entity was also named as a criminal suspect.
 
There was no dispute regarding the issuance of the tax invoices or the payment of funds. If the transaction were deemed to constitute subcontracting, the CEO could face criminal liability and the corporation could also be held liable under the joint penalty provisions. As a company operating in the specialty construction industry, the matter posed a significant burden on its business operations.
 

2. Key Issues
① Whether the insulation work was directly performed by the client or subcontracted to Mr. A
The critical issue was whether the relationship between the client and Mr. A constituted a subcontracting arrangement or an employment (or service) relationship. Under the applicable legal standards, the determining factors were not the form of the contract or the existence of a business registration, but rather who bore the material costs, who employed the workers, and who exercised direction and supervision over the construction site.
 
② Nature of the tax invoices issued under Mr. A's name and the related payments
Another issue was whether the transaction structure, under which Mr. A issued tax invoices under his sole proprietorship and the client made payments, constituted subcontracting payments or reimbursement of site-related expenses.
 
③ Whether corporate liability under the joint penalty provisions could be established
The authorities also considered whether the corporation could be held liable for failing to exercise due care if no criminal liability could be established against the CEO.
 

3. Key Defense Strategy
One Law Partners, LLC based its defense on the standards established by the Korean Supreme Court in Case No. 2018Du43330. The Supreme Court held that worker status should be determined not by the form of the contract but by the existence of a substantive relationship of subordination. One Law Partners, LLC submitted materials to the investigative authorities comparing each of these legal criteria with the facts of the case.
 
First, the firm demonstrated that Mr. A was not an independent contractor but rather an employee affiliated with the client company. The client managed Mr. A as its employee and paid his social insurance contributions and Construction Workers Mutual Aid Association contributions. The client also directly bore all material costs and labor costs for more than 20 workers assigned to the project. In addition, the firm established that the client directly directed and supervised the construction work, including through safety training conducted by the CEO and risk assessments carried out by the site manager.
 
The firm further explained that the tax invoice transactions did not constitute subcontract payments. Instead, they reflected reimbursement of site expenses initially paid by the site manager on behalf of the project. The defense also presented case law recognizing that the existence of a business registration alone does not negate employee status.
 
The prosecutor determined that the transactions could reasonably be viewed as expense reimbursements. The prosecutor also considered the facts that the client paid wages to Mr. A, enrolled him in the national health insurance system, directly employed the site workers, and that an acquittal in favor of Mr. A had already become final and conclusive. As a result, the prosecutor concluded that it was difficult to definitively establish that subcontracting had occurred and issued a non-prosecution decision (no charges) for the CEO. The prosecutor reached the same conclusion with respect to the corporation, finding that, absent criminal liability on the part of the CEO, the corporation could not be deemed to have violated any duty of care.
 

4. Significance of the Case
At construction sites, it is common for site managers to initially incur project-related expenses and for the company to reimburse those expenses afterward. However, when tax invoices are issued under the site manager's name during that process, third parties may mistakenly view the arrangement as unlicensed subcontracting.
 
This case demonstrates that, in determining whether such transactions constitute actual subcontracting, the decisive factors are the substantive circumstances, including who bore the material costs, who employed and managed the workers and their social insurance coverage, and who exercised direction and supervision over the construction work.
 
As a result, both the CEO and the corporate entity were relieved of criminal liability. However, this outcome was based on the specific facts of this case and the evidence submitted to the authorities. Even where a similar transaction structure exists, the conclusion may differ depending on the particular circumstances involved.
 
-
Joun-Woo Park, Attorney | jwpark@onelawpartners.com
Jeong-Min Ha, Attorney | jmha@onelawpartners.com
-
Public Relations Team, One Law Partners, LLC | pr@onelawpartners.com


SNS Share 페이스북 공유하기트위터 공유하기네이버 공유하기