errorPlease register the sub image.

Selected Cases

General Civil Litigation,Registration, Compulsory Execution & Deposit

Costs Reimbursement Claim: Securing a Supreme Court En Banc Ruling Awarding Delay Damages

  • Date 2026.11.20
  • Hit 35

One Law Partners, LLC successfully represented the plaintiff in a reimbursement claim case and obtained a landmark Supreme Court en banc decision overturning the lower court and appellate court (original judgment), both of which had held that claims for delay damages and related amounts were procedurally improper. The Supreme Court recognized entitlement to delay damages accruing from the day following the decision confirming the amount of execution costs.
 
1. Case Overview
The client incurred expenses in carrying out an obligation that the opposing party had failed to perform as promised. Subsequently, through court proceedings to determine the amount of execution costs, the amount to be reimbursed by the opposing party was fixed.
 
The opposing party paid only the principal amount stated in the execution cost determination decision, maintaining that there was no obligation to pay delay damages. However, upon review, the client concluded that delay damages accruing after the expenditure of the costs should also be payable.
 
According to the client’s calculation, the amount paid by the opposing party was insufficient to satisfy all delay damages and related amounts, and application of the rules governing appropriation of payments meant that additional sums remained outstanding. Accordingly, the client filed a reimbursement claim action.
 
The court of first instance and the appellate court dismissed the action, holding that, once a decision determining the amount of execution costs had been issued, payment could not be sought through a separate civil action. The client appealed to the Supreme Court, challenging both the procedural propriety of the claims and the scope of additional amounts recoverable.
 
 
2. Key Issues
First, the issue was whether the client held a claim that could be asserted independently of the execution cost determination procedure with respect to the expenses incurred. This required examination of both the basis on which the expenses had been incurred and the effects of the related judgments.
 
Second, the court considered whether delay damages not included in the existing execution cost determination decision could be claimed through a separate lawsuit. The dispute centered on whether the existence of a decision regarding the principal amount of execution costs also barred a claim for delay damages.
 
Third, the case raised the question of when delay damages begin to accrue and how any remaining debt should be calculated in light of the order of appropriation of payments made by the opposing party.
 
 
3. Key Litigation Strategy
One Law Partners, LLC reviewed the related judgments, the execution cost determination decision, and the history of the client's expenditures and payments, and organized the legal basis for the client’s claims.
 
In the petition for appeal, the firm challenged the lower court’s ruling by addressing the legal nature of the reimbursement claim and the effect of the prior final judgment. The appeal further raised the issue of whether the client’s asserted rights and the amounts arising from delayed payment could be adjudicated in a separate action.
 
The Supreme Court interpreted the plaintiff’s claims as including a claim for delay damages on the confirmed execution costs. Because the existing cost determination decision did not specify delay damages, the Court held that there was a legitimate interest in bringing a separate action to seek such payment.
 
The Court further applied delay damages accruing from the day following the date on which the cost determination decision became final, together with the relevant rules governing appropriation of payments. As a result, it found that a portion of the principal execution costs remained outstanding and directly ordered payment of delay damages on that remaining principal amount. Accordingly, the relevant portions of both the appellate judgment and the first-instance judgment were reversed and vacated.
 
4. Significance of the Case
This case is significant because it established a new Supreme Court precedent by departing from decades of prior case law, which held that, in cases involving cost determination decisions, the obligation to perform arose only when the decision became final and the debtor became aware of it, such that default liability arose only thereafter. The Supreme Court held that, with respect to execution cost determination decisions, delay damages accrue from the time the cost determination decision becomes final, consistent with the treatment of litigation cost determination decisions. For the client, the case is particularly meaningful because it reversed the conclusion reached by the appellate court and recognized the client’s claim for payment of delay damages.
 
In addition, this case is significant in that it produced an explicit Supreme Court ruling on default interest in relation to litigation costs and enforcement costs, an issue that had previously drawn little attention.
 
For decades, claims for litigation costs and enforcement costs in proceedings to determine such costs had, as a matter of practice, been limited to the principal amount. Attorneys at One Law Partners, LLC questioned this long-standing practice and pursued the case based on the argument that default interest should also be recognized for enforcement costs. Through this decision, not only were the starting points for the accrual of default interest on litigation costs and enforcement costs clarified, but it also brought about a significant change in the claims and adjudication methods applied in all cases involving claims for litigation costs and enforcement costs. In this respect, the ruling carries considerable significance.
 
-
Yong-Rahk Shin, Attorney | yrshin@onelawpartners.com
Jeong-Ik Oh, Attorney | jioh@onelawpartners.com
Yong-Hyeon Han, Attorney | yhhan@onelawpartners.com
-
Public Relations Team, One Law Partners, LLC | pr@onelawpartners.com


SNS Share 페이스북 공유하기트위터 공유하기네이버 공유하기